Wednesday, February 9, 2011
Unexpected Environmental Impacts
Comment on this post to leave your description of the "unexpected environmental impact" you were going to discuss in class today. Sorry again that my flight was delayed and I was unable to make it to class!
Artificially Natural
A question was raised to me by my father after speaking about our human endeavors of space colonization and travel. If nature is everything natural and everything created by man is artificial, then any tree planted or animal raised is artificial. So logic dictates. In that case, what of terraforming? Say that a humanity comes to possess a power able to transform an entire planet into a lush, green paradise, such as the Genesis device created in the movie Star Trek II. We discussed in class the value of nature and whether or not it is inherently valuable or only seemingly so due to human opinion. If it is the latter, terraforming would be seen as a good thing, especially if it made the planet more hospitable to supporting human life; however, if the prior is true, then the alterations, whether they be to a barren planet or otherwise, would be seen as destroying the natural setting. So the destruction by creation is therefore artificial and since artificiality is not nature and nature holds intrinsic value, the false nature must not. Is this true? What of seeding a planet to grow on its own with time? Would the first step nullify the value of all that which comes forth from the initial? Perhaps to humanity, but what of the creatures who come to value that artificial nature as we value our own? Imagine now that the nature which we deem valuable is in fact created by a group of beings capable of doing such planet seeding. Does that mean that all which we find beauty and loveliness in our natural world is really a lie? Something fabricated by intelligent hands to become something mimicking the creations of the universe's original? Perhaps. Perhaps we simply are all artificial in a means. We are all a product of human reproduction which was only made possible by our race's overall survival which was done through our own intervention against extinction. In our quest for survival, are we not in fact relying on alterations done by our own or forefathers' hands? Every vine cut to clear a path, every seed planted, and every stone turned can be deemed artificially changed. In order to survive, we must alter. We are then a product of our alterations and must then be artificial.
Sunday, February 6, 2011
Ethics of Meat
The Environment and its Studies: Meat and the Environment
One topic that is rarely brought up when discussing environmental ethics is that of meat. There are many different ethical dilemmas surrounding meat ranging from killing animals for food to the ethics of how you raise animals for food. A study suggests that we tax meat in order to encourage people to buy and eat less meat. This raises a few concerns over the fact that the government would be telling people what to eat in a way. Is it more ethical to tell people what they have to eat or to help the save the planet? Can we even compare the two results at all?
The next ethical problem is about growing meat in test tubes. At first glance, test tube meat would not only solve the ethical problems of killing animals but it would also help the environment by eliminating one of the leading greenhouse gas producers. Test tube meat, is in a since vegan meat because no animals were hurt in the making of it. Yet is the ethical problem only as ethereal as killing animals or is it the fact that we are just finding an alternative to an already destructive mindset. We raise animals for the sole purpose of food and this would be the same thing but on a faster and easier process. Can you consider test tube grown meat alive at all? Or is it just processed food? Can it solve the future global food crisis or is it creating even more problems by allowing for an increase in population?
Saturday, February 5, 2011
Foundations of Environmental Thought
Recent public polls indicate that we aren't the only ones who are concerned about the environment and how it is being treated. 50 percent of the surveyed Americans show a concern for water pollution, while 75 percent of those surveyed show concern for things such as; acid rain, nuclear waste, and of course global warming. Concern for the environment hasn't always been this evident. So what has caused such an uproar amongst American people in the recent past? It's the politicians says Steiguer, author of Foundations of Environmental Thought. We are all guilty of gluing ourselves to the television during times of election and economic turmoil, and the environment has recently become a major topic of discussion amongst our politicians. This raised public awareness about the environment, in my opinion, is a great thing. The more the public knows, the more that environmental issues will be looked at, and hopefully fixed.
Friday, February 4, 2011
fantastic book, intro Enviro. Thought
The chapters from de Steugger's Origins of Modern Enviromental Thought have been my favorites so far in our Environmental Philosphy class. The book serves I think the best possible introduction to the environmental ideas and movement as 'beginnings' within books and papers by the 'great' thinkers who put to paper thoughts that must be considered in our modern society with the continuation of our human lives and the health of our planet in mind. That some major political acts are included goes of course further to show how much progress has been made (even if some are not as far-reaching or have been stripped in their scope in the semi-recent years). I enjoyed the brief talks about St. Francis of Assissi and also some of the older philosophers who wrote about overpopulation and recognize how their thoughts cause today's and yeasterday's thinkers to take direction. That Emerson and Thoreau have consistently encouraged the works of other environmentalist is very heartening, Thoreau even being often voted as the most influential of environmentalists I find neat - leave it to a subject as holistic as environmental philosophy to give a poet mass credit. I look forward to reading the chapters that were not covered in the assignment and will use this book as a starting point for my initial extracurricular readings. Ive already ordered Silent Spring and most look forward to reading Naess' literature on the Deep Ecology and Roderick Nash's Wilderness and the American Mind. Im sure I will be propelled by these writings to learn more and I anticipate learning about the more international personalities like Schweitzer and the framers of the Kyoto Protocol.
"Spaceship Earth"
The world around us is full of vital natural resources for plant, human and animal survival. Without plentiful energy resources for every individual the consequences would literally turn deadly fast. Kenneth Boulding believed that the Earth is similar to a spaceship in that the resources are limited and will eventually run out. He referred to earlier in history as the "cowboy economy," which was a time where humans used resources as if their was an endless, limitless supply of natural goods.
Throughout the years people began to realize more and more that we need to conserve our resources especially with constantly rising number of human inhabitants on Earth. In fact, today's Earth carrying capacity is nearly, if not on the brink of being full. Earth cannot expand to encompass more life, air cannot be fixed from hundreds of decades of harmful toxins, and extinct plants and animals can never be replaced, but people can do their part today by conserving natural resources and disposing of wastes in more environmentally safe ways. Environmentally safe practices can continue to take place even with the advancing of technology. Instead of using harmful methods of powering new electronics, homes, and buildings we can use the constant energy from the sun, which makes.
Boulding considered ways to improve lively hood and natural resources. Kenneth's essay was primarily over the topic entropy in the forms of energy, matter and information. Using the second law of thermodynamics Mr. Boulding realized that entropy "places a absolute limit on the viability of civilization." Everyone needs to work together and not use too many resources for a spaceship to stay intact. People must constantly be making repairs and better the ship/environment for it to sustain the old, new, and incoming life forms.
Throughout the years people began to realize more and more that we need to conserve our resources especially with constantly rising number of human inhabitants on Earth. In fact, today's Earth carrying capacity is nearly, if not on the brink of being full. Earth cannot expand to encompass more life, air cannot be fixed from hundreds of decades of harmful toxins, and extinct plants and animals can never be replaced, but people can do their part today by conserving natural resources and disposing of wastes in more environmentally safe ways. Environmentally safe practices can continue to take place even with the advancing of technology. Instead of using harmful methods of powering new electronics, homes, and buildings we can use the constant energy from the sun, which makes.
Boulding considered ways to improve lively hood and natural resources. Kenneth's essay was primarily over the topic entropy in the forms of energy, matter and information. Using the second law of thermodynamics Mr. Boulding realized that entropy "places a absolute limit on the viability of civilization." Everyone needs to work together and not use too many resources for a spaceship to stay intact. People must constantly be making repairs and better the ship/environment for it to sustain the old, new, and incoming life forms.
Foundations of Environmental Thought
While reading the excerpt from Foundations of Environmental Thought, the ideas of John Stuart Mill peaked my interest. His Utopian way of thinking is quite clear. In summary, he believed that it is the selfishness of human kind that is destroying the environment. He thought that man needed to get back to a more simple way of life, and stop trying to be better and get more than their neighbor. While these ideals do make some sense, it is not quite practical. The whole idea of a Utopian society can never be. We are, after all, only human. Man will always be wanting more no matter how much one may have. The problem is that we have unlimited wants with limited resources. This is where we find ourselves in trouble with the environment. Rather than man being content with what he currently has, whether it be land, wealth, or food, he is never satisfied. Even though he may have more than he needs to sustain life, he still will trample and destroy anything in his path to get more of what he wants. It is true that there is plenty of resources on this earth to obliterate all world hunger, however, the selfishness of man kind will always prevent this from happening. Anther theory of Mill's was that human population can only reach a certain number before we start to out use our natural resources. It is very easy to see and understand how this is true. The environment can only preserve and sustain its' natural resources at a certain rate. The greater the human population, the more resources will be in demand. This also cuts down on the time that the environment is able to regrow more resources. Unfortunately, there is just no practical way to control human population without getting into the obvious ethical issues.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)